My appologies for the terrible quality of the image but its just a picture from my phone of the graph of the hot plate, embedded steel plate and surface steel plate temperture to give you a better idea of what I am talking about. I wasn't able to upload the actual file because company computers don't allow that no matter how harmless it really is in this case (random experiment data). Also I apologize for cutting the data a bit short but I ran out of time friday afternoon but I think it demonstrates my issue. According to this the surface temp exceeds the hot plate temp after about 30 minutes. The hot plate temp oscillates just by its settings, once it reaches its set temp it stops heating for a minute or two then turns on again until it reaches its temp and so on. So after looking over the comments most believe it is sensor error? Does this data make any differences to anyones opinion?
and to reiterate, there is an aluminum foil cover laying on top of the steel plate. Not a perfect lid but more like a blanket over it (there is air between them).