It appears this is one of those topics where we can become mired in definitions, semantics and phenomena that we can observe but perhaps not fully comprehend. As a layman(sorry, layperson) I have only had time for intellectual excursions like this since retiring. Many very interesting arguments in this particular thread. I wonder where what we call 'instinct' might fit here. Animals that are aware of benefits / risks in their environment should have a better chance of survival (during their particular era...am aware of extinction). So if successful response to challenges or opportunities makes them more successful at survival, it would appear some traits would be passed on to offspring, and into successive generations. This seems like a behavioral imperative, and an evolutionary advantage, determining responses to the environment. Did it originate in ancestral consciousness, or am I wandering into the realm of, "Who knows, who cares'?