Andrew William Henderson

Nothing in nature happens twice ... twice one of the SAME Same = exact or it's not the same Similar = not exact If a second attempt of Abiogenesis be it here or planet zog is restricted to its initial ingredients and physical circumstances those restrictions ( pressures) are non reputable so whatever it can produce wont be biology it's not about a different type of evolution it's only made another chemical reaction that has it's own immediate future enviroment to contend with .it has intent or purpose or intellgence to become a similar chemical reaction found on earth ..if you can give an example of two dissimilar chemical and physical processes that produce the same thing again ...twice ...a 2nd time ..if not let's hope extraterrestrial lifeforms are the first 🙂 you dig ?

To do it twice it would defy entrophy and if you got it at a identical position of the process with a guaranteed future enviroment exactly as it happened here ( if we knew ) the Lorenz effect shows we can predict the outcome but not the exact outcome ... your making a an assumption that basic biolgy was basic in its construction as its construction is said to be relatively fast from the earths formation ...why would that be a starting point of the process ...an important one I agree but not as important as its postion and initial ingredients

No it will not ..gold formation is mainly a geological process that requires less circumstance , gold is a easy process as it is still been formed today hower all the Ingredients of life that would make a astrobiologist wee his pants is found in your garden however unlike gold we see not even quarter attempts of an Abiogenesis 2 gold still has its mechanical and physical processes ..Abiology hasn't because its process was too conveluted and open to more circumstance than mineral pressure in a fissure

At what point in time will they all be exact ....I agree they have no individuality but they can never be exact

I'm not ...its because there is goal posts at either end ..There not moving ...No other system or process can produce gold again ..twice the same! And the other end of the pitch ..nothing happens twice not gold or you ! So why biology here or anywhere else happen again ...biology isnt a mountain or gold biology production required more circumstance than a mountain yet we see no Mount Everest 2

It wasnt a question ....the title is why we are alone not why are we alone...its statement of point The same thing Happening twice = the same thing Same = exact Similar = not exact The point is no other reactions found in nature despite been logically less complex than abiology are observed ....suns don't happen twice there resulting planetary system don't nor the resulting set of circumstance placed on it and its planets ...what magic is used to allow Abiogenesis to bypass entropy and the Lorenz effect

What your not taking into account is ..the reason the product isn't the same ( gold) is because the process isnt the same just similar enough to produce our definition of gold ..the process is just a product of an earlier process ... Happening twice = the same thing happening twice Same= exact Similar = not exact ....!

Well would you expect to find a identical gold ring even if you had the access to them ...the gold found in California can be distinguished from gold found in Queensland ...the amount of circumstance to form gold is obvisously less than the amount to form biology ...

"We humans "sorry ...I hope you didnt think I was A.I. from the future or lord GORDOR king of the martians ..🙂 They are just not the same they are just similar at a picoscopic level ..there properties are not even exact ...

Actually they are not identical at all ..the atomic particles of copper are not the same they are modeled by humans to have mathmatical properties.. a clone isnt something happening twice at what point was it identical.? once exposed to exsitence it was never the same identical human twins would have more dissimilar attributes than similar dispite the obvious asthetics...a particular monkey species does not happen twice and the monkey species can not produce an identical individual from another ...would you expect a grain of sand to have an exact duplicate ...? So why a complex chemical reaction forged by unreatable mechanical circumstance ...? Examples please ....if two seperate chemical processes can produce the same product ...are you able to distinguish each end product from each other ....a native example would be Could iron and custard make a identical and indistinguishable product from nitrogen and cheese ....

Which one is the eye then ....the eye in reality is collection of cells that collect light ...spiders have legs and often as hairy as humans ...eyes are just a collective word ..The octopuses concept and interpretation of light into the reality of its surroundings is not the way other body models see things ...convergent evoulution isnt a species happening again just a similar shape ..fish been a good example .. If it's not biology how could it be biology ...? Another process from totally unique circumstance and material and point in time is not observed in nature to produce the same thing ...the laws of physics may be universal but its effects are not ..!

The question of extraterrestrial lifeforms ability to exsit rests on probability....the probabilty of been the first instance of a natural process not only of happening twice but producing the same phenomena twice ....why would biology happen again if Abiogenesis is required to happen again first?....Nothing in nature is observered to happen again or twice ...have a look yourselves! The indistinguishable particle from the field of quantum physics only remains so to you humans as of yet .... other lesser complex mechanical/chemical reactions are yet to be observed to produce anything twice or the same again ...Is extraterrestrial biology destined to be the first rather than copper happening twice .. A.Henderson June 2021