Potential truth behind aphantasia
I propose that the development of aphantasia, characterized by the inability to form mental images, is influenced by one's early upbringing and experiences. I suggest that the absence of mental imagery is a result of specific factors during the formative years, such as the dominant sensory modality relied upon and individual cognitive tendencies.
For instance, individuals who heavily rely on visual stimuli during their upbringing may be more inclined to engage in visual imagination. In contrast, those who heavily rely on auditory input may naturally lean towards an auditory-focused monologue. This preference or bias in mental processes can potentially be influenced by various factors, including early experiences, upbringing, and individual cognitive tendencies.
To test the validity of this theory, I propose conducting an experiment with two groups of individuals who would undergo a monitored upbringing. The goal would be to expose one group to a higher amount of visual input, while the other group receives a higher amount of auditory input.