futurewatch

Hi, my first post, been searching the subject matter found this thread interesting so I like to join in. I am interested in a prospective on the merits of the SEG concept or lack of it. Which appears to be sorely lacking here, why? Upon reviewing the device on searlsolution site, I see how we can address it by its technical points, by its design merits and its theory of operation in a systematic matter and see what we learn. The first question - I have for Mr. Skeptic is why are you applying second law to a device that is described as an open system and not a closed one? Second question - Does it qualify as a generator and a motor? third - Is it possible for this design to manifest a quantum Hall effect where energy conversion is said to take place? That all for starters, of course I welcome physicist here that don’t fear to tread beyond the status quo and are free to express their opinion. Thanks...