geordief
Senior Members-
Posts
3358 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
3
geordief last won the day on March 8
geordief had the most liked content!
Recent Profile Visitors
21818 profile views
geordief's Achievements
Scientist (10/13)
214
Reputation
-
Would that also likely represent the overall population (on those platforms ,none of which I personally take part in) or just the political leanings of the "news influencers" in them?(do you think) Edit :males are more trusted as influencers,perhaps and they skewed right in this election?
-
In terms of technical ability?
-
Are you talking about Canada? I am not sure I follow your point. You don't think the "working class" seek to better their economic situation? That they remain "working class" even when they succeed in this? Are you talking about their self image ?
-
How do we measure the degree of "change" between 2 systems?
geordief replied to geordief's topic in Relativity
Yes ,I think I was perhaps thinking along those lines. I seem to want to describe or measure a "system as a whole" and am coming to the realization that a system may be the "sum" of its internal relationships and moreover the concept seems to run foul of the idea that there is no absolute time or space. Any system cannot be fixed -only approximated as such. Still ,with my solar system example of 1,2,3 states if the third system was disturbed by a massive black hole would we have no hesitation in agreeing that the change between 3 and 1 was greater than that between 2 and 1? We would have to show that one variable at a time and then stick them all together to model the system "as a whole"? -
How do we measure the degree of "change" between 2 systems?
geordief replied to geordief's topic in Relativity
I wasn't sure where to post really but I often post in relativity and thought it might be quite close I am indeed worrying about where Earth is relative to Jupiter but I think you may be saying that the Sun's reference frame "includes" that information . Can we say that for a complete system it is possible to describe it by using any chosen reference point and that all the individual relationships can be bound up in that one reference point? From my lowly knowledge status I wonder whether I can doubt it (or if I have expressed myself at all cogently) -
How do we measure the degree of "change" between 2 systems?
geordief replied to geordief's topic in Relativity
Your "abstract space" is that a timeless concept? Is my question ,then connected to entropy? Another example of two differing systems could be a shuffled pack of cards and ,in these cases I have feeling that entropy might be a method of comparing one arrangement of the cards versus another. Still ,my initial example specified that one arrangement derived from the other...so I think time entered the frame,unlike the pack of cards. -
How do we measure the degree of "change" between 2 systems?
geordief replied to geordief's topic in Relativity
It could be ,on the macro level the arrangement of the solar system (discounting its position in the galaxy) We have some 10(?) main objects-planets (let's discount the Sun for simplicity ) At 12 midday our time the various planets are set out in an arrangement and 12 midnight we have a new arrangement At 12 midday the next day there is a third arrangement Calling the arrangents 1,2,3 can we measure how much 2 is changed from 1 and does 3 change from 1 to a greater degree? I am not sure whether or not the lapse of time enters into any calculation or whether the configurations "stand alone" as it were. I think it is unarguble that changes have happened but can we measure that change for the system as a whole or just by comparing individual components of one system against individual components of the other system. -
Suppose we have 2 systems ,one of which derives from the other how can one measure the difference between them (the amount of "change")? Can we assume that the first system is comprised of n constituent parts and the other m constituent parts since these parts can interact and destroy/create themselves? Do we have to connect the two systems with an array of "lines of causality "?
-
Has there been any suggestion that a husband should be expected to vote in accordance with his wife's preferences?
-
One of the most pointless phrases to learn in another language
geordief replied to Janus's topic in The Lounge
Janus was giving the occasional Finish lesson (a semi blog) in the old thescienceforum.org website that folded this year. ...things move on. -
One of the most pointless phrases to learn in another language
geordief replied to Janus's topic in The Lounge
-
That "ideology" would apply to any sub group of society an individual might identify with. They all seem to embody their own code of behaviour. I was just watching a documentary (Sam Willis) about the pirates in the Carribean and Africa who developed their own rules and apparently became something of an attractive counter culture in the 18th century Britain ("live a short but licentious life or a Puritanical one if you joined up with Captain Bart") https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bartholomew_Roberts https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b06qn3lr
-
I wonder what we would define as a moral decision or an admonition and when this could have first come into play as we evolved as a species. Is it by definition a kind of social contract and did it arise as some kind of an attempt to put on the record then ,that there are times when the short term benefit of a decision can lead to longer term harmful consequences? Whoever was responsible for "laying down" this new prescription for action (or their "disciples" ) may have felt the need to justify their advice to their more headstrong colleagues and (heaven forbid) invented an imaginary friend(conveniently dead ,possibly) who had told them this The rest ,as they say .. I also wonder if there is evidence of moral codes in other species that do not have the benefit of being able to record their conversations with each other.(ie all of them?)
-
Does the photon only "know" that the electric and the magnetic fields ** are interacting? (is that actually what the photon "is"?) Does that pass for change in its world? What can happen for the photon for this process itself to change? (can the photon "die"?) **is it important to distinguish between a "field as a set of measurements" and a field as a fundamental bedrock of nature? Are the two fields making up the photon's existence part of the wider universal electric and magnetic fields?