I have to agree about A Trip's statements and I treat the opinions of michel123456 accordingly. A Trip's example is well placed because michel123456 is someone many might find difficult to properly evaluate. I don't however, agree that it is always simple to identify someone as not being adequately equipped to properly convey the ideas that are often presented in these forums (i.e. michel123456). Should A Trip speak his mind? In a polite fashion absolutely! I'm not saying everyone should run around slandering everyone, I'm saying that if the issue came up it is probably best to speak your mind in a 'mature' fashion--I really can't emphasize mature enough. Others might not be aware of the reliability of the source that is speaking, even though really it is entirely on their shoulders to filter the information that they are choosing to absorb.
Should mods need to fully disclose their credentials? Absolutely not! There are enough people here that know the material that if a mod was full of B.S. they would be identified. If someone doesn't like the mods opinions they can choose to ignore their efforts and advices, and are always welcome to leave.
+1 This is the first thing that has ever come out of iNow that I've ever agreed with; I usually limit my reading of his material as it tends to be topics that I am not interested in.
The fact of the matter is someone will catch on or see it and most things are corrected at some point, and this will improve as the community grows. Which circles back to the OP and why some threads are treated with less respect than others. As far as I am aware--rules presented, the people who participate, general attitudes--the forum operates under the pretense that all information presented is to the effect of presenting ideas that are correct inside of science, and this is in fact not a place to haphazardly develop ideas that have flimsy foundations, period. I say this as someone who has spent a lot of time here and I hope you find a place be it here or elsewhere that you can find comfort in doing what it is you do!
Again to the OP, my brother recently made a discovery. He suddenly came to the realization that dark matter would in fact be made of dark atoms. If he opened a thread in main physics and it sat there what would that say about the forum?