-
Posts
25528 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
133
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Everything posted by Strange
-
Is race a valid concept?
Strange replied to Mikemikev's topic in Evolution, Morphology and Exobiology
So why did you say that when I asked how you defined race? I didn't ask what the cause was. "Tang 2005" is not very precise at all. I tried googling but just came up with lots of seemingly irrelevant results. I did ask you to clarify but apparently you couldn't be bothered to be precise. A precise reference would be, for example: Tang, N. and Cousins, C. (2005), Working Time, Gender and Family: An East-West European Comparison. Gender, Work & Organization, 12: 527–550. doi: 10.1111/j.1468-0432.2005.00287.x -
Is race a valid concept?
Strange replied to Mikemikev's topic in Evolution, Morphology and Exobiology
Your definition (below) just seems a little arbitrary and subjective (things like "You can split off the Japanese or whatever"). What is disparaging about that? -
Who was Abraham that religions get named after him?
Strange replied to Robittybob1's topic in Religion
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abraham -
Is race a valid concept?
Strange replied to Mikemikev's topic in Evolution, Morphology and Exobiology
Very droll. Who said it was? -
How do you define "better"? The universe may well be in decline. In fact it obviously is. It is expanding and cooling. Eventually we will not be able to see any other galaxies. On what basis do you say it would be unlikely to last 12 billion years? Can you show the calculations that lead you to that conclusion? Again, what does "better" mean? Also, stars form and die but eventually the conditions for creating new stars will be gone and no new stars will form. Then the last star will die and the universe will be cold and dark. IS that "better"? What is there, on Earth, that recognises beneficial change? What is there, in stars and galaxies, that can be described as reproduction?
-
Is race a valid concept?
Strange replied to Mikemikev's topic in Evolution, Morphology and Exobiology
But you weren't describing genomic similarity (or it didn't sound like you were). No. Enligheten me. -
Is race a valid concept?
Strange replied to Mikemikev's topic in Evolution, Morphology and Exobiology
Sounds a little ... unspecific. How would you quantify these things for the purpose of a scientific analysis? -
Please show us exactly what the nature of this problem is.
-
Ridiculous Reproductive Principle--A Testable Hypothesis
Strange replied to B. John Jones's topic in Speculations
No it doesn't. As evidenced by the fact that many in the scientific community are religious. -
That is where you seem to leave logic and take off into science fiction (or Creationism). There is NO logical reason why there should be any such systems in place. The Earth came about by chance, we happened to have evolved while conditions were favourable. If conditions change (perhaps because we change them) we may not find it easy to survive. The nearest thing to what you are describing is perhaps that fact that if we were to be driven to extinction then other species would thrive in our place.
-
Ridiculous Reproductive Principle--A Testable Hypothesis
Strange replied to B. John Jones's topic in Speculations
This sounds like a version of Lamarckian inheritance, which has been shown not to work. Also, if such a system did work, don't you think that it would be in use after millennia of breeding of plants and animals? Also: burden of proof. Your hypothesis, you need to provide evidence. -
Thoughts On Dark Matter
Strange replied to TheoreticalCheckmate's topic in Modern and Theoretical Physics
And there are no items of infinite mass. The rest makes equally little sense. -
It may dissolve the rest of the rock as well! (I am assuming, perhaps wrongly, that the OP wanted to remove the quartz inclusions from the volcanic rock....)
-
Thoughts On Dark Matter
Strange replied to TheoreticalCheckmate's topic in Modern and Theoretical Physics
I am not aware of any models where dark matter can decay into normal matter (but that doesn't mean there aren't any). There are some models where dark matter can annihilate to produce photons. What do you mean by producing time? Time is a dimension. -
Is race a valid concept?
Strange replied to Mikemikev's topic in Evolution, Morphology and Exobiology
This is discussion forum. You raised the topic, I assumed you were happy to discuss it. I don't know anything about it so I apologise if my questions seem trivial to you. -
Unfair closure of race and intelligence thread
Strange replied to Mikemikev's topic in Suggestions, Comments and Support
If you feel there is some such bias, there probably isn't much you can do about it. Other than find another forum more to your liking. There is no rule that says an Internet forum has to be fair. -
Is race a valid concept?
Strange replied to Mikemikev's topic in Evolution, Morphology and Exobiology
So what are these 5? (And do you have some sort of reference tot he definition?) Does that mean "what people declare themselves to be"? -
Is race a valid concept?
Strange replied to Mikemikev's topic in Evolution, Morphology and Exobiology
As I think some have said, at some level (if we go back far enough) there is only 1. Where does the 5 come from? How does ancestry define 5 groups of humans? (Ditto for 30.) What is "SIRE"? (I did try googling quickly, but didn't see anything immediately relevant.) -
Is race a valid concept?
Strange replied to Mikemikev's topic in Evolution, Morphology and Exobiology
OK. So I gather you are interested in using this concept is scientific studies. How would you evaluate and quantify this, for that purpose? For example, would you need to look at the family history of each participant in the study? And if so, how many generations back? And if not, do you use something else as a proxy for ancestry? -
Is race a valid concept?
Strange replied to Mikemikev's topic in Evolution, Morphology and Exobiology
How many races are there in your system? What race would you assign to someone with ancestors, in the last few generations, who were Chinese, Berber, San, Thai, Indian, Arabian, Norway, Inuit, Sicilian, Mexican? Is that the same race as someone with ancestors, in the last few generations, who were Chinese, Polynesian, San, Thai, Indian, Arabian, Norway, Inuit, Sicilian, Mexican? -
Is race a valid concept?
Strange replied to Mikemikev's topic in Evolution, Morphology and Exobiology
That appears to be an example of the etymological fallacy. A hypothesis or theory can be shown to be wrong, but that does not make it pseudoscience. Newtonian gravity is "wrong" (at some level) that doesn't make it pseudoscience. Phlogiston theory is wrong, but it wasn't pseudoscience. The steady state universe model is wrong, but it wasn't pseudoscience. -
Rupert Sheldrake theory of morphic resonace
Strange replied to RomeViharo's topic in Evolution, Morphology and Exobiology
Do you have any evidence that supports this idea? -
Are you talking about throwing it up in the air? Or providing it with rocket engines? Or something else? (The answers may be different in each case.) And why an umbrella? It will require just as much energy to keep an umbrella in the air as any other object if the same weight. Unless the shape of the umbrella happens to be a good aerofoil, which is possible I suppose...