Scott alan miles Posted August 4, 2020 Posted August 4, 2020 What if Jupiter was closer to Saturn at one point(perhaps while traveling after the Big Bang) and instead of gravity we use magnetism and the moons on Saturn got crushed because it was negatively charged and Saturn and Jupiter where possitive. The result would be negatively charged rocks caught in a possitive field. It would help explain why the rocks sit in place ( Jupiter and Saturn new distance would lock most in space. And why the globes never reformed. No possitive there. It’s a nice stretch anyways.
Ghideon Posted August 4, 2020 Posted August 4, 2020 Why would we use magnetism instead of gravity ? Is this a question or a speculative idea?
Scott alan miles Posted August 4, 2020 Author Posted August 4, 2020 Because aren’t you sick of using something that still can’t be found. I mean cern claimed to find the higs boson. But wo look , they found 4 separate other yet known particles and magnetism works without that horrible space time crud. Also it works in 3 dimensions length height width. Possitive negative neutralizing
Strange Posted August 4, 2020 Posted August 4, 2020 ! Moderator Note Moved to Speculations. (I must be feeling very generous.) 1 hour ago, Scott alan miles said: What if Jupiter was closer to Saturn at one point What evidence do you have for that? 1 hour ago, Scott alan miles said: perhaps while traveling after the Big Bang Can you explain how you think the Big Bang might be relevant? 1 hour ago, Scott alan miles said: and instead of gravity we use magnetism and the moons on Saturn got crushed because it was negatively charged and Saturn and Jupiter where possitive. Are you talking about magnetism (where each object has both a north and south pole) or electric charge where things are either negative or positive? 1 hour ago, Scott alan miles said: The result would be negatively charged rocks caught in a possitive field. It would help explain why the rocks sit in place Why wouldn't all the negatively charged rocks repel each other and disrupt the rings? How strong are these fields you are talking about? Can you calculate the forces involved to show that your idea is plausible? 45 minutes ago, Scott alan miles said: Because aren’t you sick of using something that still can’t be found. Do you not have gravity where you live? Do you have to tie yourself to your chair while typing? 45 minutes ago, Scott alan miles said: I mean cern claimed to find the higs boson. How is that related to the [non]existence of gravity? 46 minutes ago, Scott alan miles said: But wo look , they found 4 separate other yet known particles They did? Can you provide a reference for this, because it is news to me. 46 minutes ago, Scott alan miles said: magnetism works without that horrible space time crud. Also it works in 3 dimensions length height width. So you don't think that length, height and width make up space? Or is it just time that doesn't exist?
Strange Posted August 4, 2020 Posted August 4, 2020 1 hour ago, Scott alan miles said: Also it works in 3 dimensions length height width. Possitive negative neutralizing Don't forget time: magnetic and electric fields propagate at the speed of light. So you have length height width time. We could do with a shorthand name for that. Oh, I know: space-time. Brilliant! And it may be worth noting that electric charges and magnetism are unified (as electromagnetism) by ... wait for it ... you're not going to like this ... relativity.
swansont Posted August 4, 2020 Posted August 4, 2020 2 hours ago, Scott alan miles said: What if Jupiter was closer to Saturn at one point(perhaps while traveling after the Big Bang) and instead of gravity we use magnetism and the moons on Saturn got crushed because it was negatively charged and Saturn and Jupiter where possitive. The result would be negatively charged rocks caught in a possitive field. It would help explain why the rocks sit in place ( Jupiter and Saturn new distance would lock most in space. And why the globes never reformed. No possitive there. It’s a nice stretch anyways. ! Moderator Note It wouldn’t explain this, but you need to understand some physics to see why. I am feeling less generous than Strange. All WAG, no science. Speculation needs some foundation in science. 2
Recommended Posts