Ralien Posted March 16 Posted March 16 Hiya , I am new here and have been considering shapes . Recently I considered the Suns shape and its apparent roundness . I then considered movement of the Sun and thought to myself if it was moving then how can it retain being a round shape . My question to you all is, If the Sun was moving , wouldn't the shape not be round ?
swansont Posted March 16 Posted March 16 Straight-line motion at constant speed has no effect - it’s exactly the same as if the object is at rest and everything else is moving. Accelerations are another matter. The sun rotates, so it’ deforms as a result. It bulges a bit at the equator, making it an oblate spheroid rather than a sphere.
Ralien Posted March 16 Author Posted March 16 On 3/16/2025 at 2:42 PM, swansont said: Straight-line motion at constant speed has no effect - it’s exactly the same as if the object is at rest and everything else is moving. Accelerations are another matter. The sun rotates, so it’ deforms as a result. It bulges a bit at the equator, making it an oblate spheroid rather than a sphere. Expand Ok , but what about at night when we see stars that are in patterns such as big dippers , these paterns are constant and have been forever . Wouldn't these patterns change if stars were moving about ?
swansont Posted March 16 Posted March 16 On 3/16/2025 at 2:50 PM, Ralien said: Ok , but what about at night when we see stars that are in patterns such as big dippers , these paterns are constant and have been forever . Wouldn't these patterns change if stars were moving about ? Expand They do change, but since stars are far away, their relative location doesn’t move much in a human lifetime, or even several lifetimes. The closest ones generally change faster, since the angular motion depends on distance, same as things on the horizon looking like they move slower than things up close. https://www.skyatnightmagazine.com/advice/constellations-move-change-over-time 1
Janus Posted March 16 Posted March 16 On 3/16/2025 at 2:50 PM, Ralien said: Ok , but what about at night when we see stars that are in patterns such as big dippers , these paterns are constant and have been forever . Wouldn't these patterns change if stars were moving about ? Expand Let's give an example of how the distance between stars and their relative speeds work. Alpha Centauri is the closest star to our own, at 4.3 ly. this is equal to 4e13 km. Our Sun orbits the galaxy a ~230 km/sec. That's 7e9 km per year. If this were the relative speed between Alpha Centauri and ourselves, then after 100 yrs, Alpha C would have shifted just 1 degree in position. But we don't move that fast relative to Alpha C. Alpha C, along with all the other stars in our local neck of the galaxy, orbits the galaxy along with us. They are not like the scenery we drive past on the road, but like other cars on the road keeping more or less the same pace as us. So the relative speeds between the stars is much smaller than that 230 km/sec, and their apparent movement in the sky that much less noticeable. 1
Ralien Posted March 16 Author Posted March 16 On 3/16/2025 at 3:17 PM, Janus said: Let's give an example of how the distance between stars and their relative speeds work. Alpha Centauri is the closest star to our own, at 4.3 ly. this is equal to 4e13 km. Our Sun orbits the galaxy a ~230 km/sec. That's 7e9 km per year. If this were the relative speed between Alpha Centauri and ourselves, then after 100 yrs, Alpha C would have shifted just 1 degree in position. But we don't move that fast relative to Alpha C. Alpha C, along with all the other stars in our local neck of the galaxy, orbits the galaxy along with us. They are not like the scenery we drive past on the road, but like other cars on the road keeping more or less the same pace as us. So the relative speeds between the stars is much smaller than that 230 km/sec, and their apparent movement in the sky that much less noticeable. Expand Your answer seems very assertive and positive but can you please answer , how we got from not been able to tell which body was moving to knowing which body was moving ?
John Cuthber Posted March 16 Posted March 16 On 3/16/2025 at 3:31 PM, Ralien said: Your answer seems very assertive and positive but can you please answer , how we got from not been able to tell which body was moving to knowing which body was moving ? Expand We can tell the earth is rotating. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foucault_pendulum 1
Ralien Posted March 16 Author Posted March 16 On 3/16/2025 at 4:28 PM, John Cuthber said: We can tell the earth is rotating. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foucault_pendulum Expand Great and I agree the Earth is rotating and it also tilts and moves compared to the Sun . However , this does not necessary mean the Sun is moving unless somebody has devised a method to show the Sun is moving ? I am at my post limit now as a new member so will not be able to further reply until tomorrow unfortunately .
swansont Posted March 16 Posted March 16 On 3/16/2025 at 3:31 PM, Ralien said: Your answer seems very assertive and positive but can you please answer , how we got from not been able to tell which body was moving to knowing which body was moving ? Expand Orbits are accelerations, and you can tell you are accelerating. But the speed was given relative to the galaxy center.
studiot Posted March 16 Posted March 16 On 3/16/2025 at 4:48 PM, Ralien said: Great and I agree the Earth is rotating and it also tilts and moves compared to the Sun . However , this does not necessary mean the Sun is moving unless somebody has devised a method to show the Sun is moving ? I am at my post limit now as a new member so will not be able to further reply until tomorrow unfortunately . Expand well done for spotting the first day post limit. Most new members don't. As regards your question, The Sun and stars are balls of firey gas. In fact they are in what we now recognise as the fourth state of matter ie plasma, which is similar to a gas but hotter. Anyway it is a fluid. I wondered if you were thinking that balls of fluid should change shape when they are translating (moving along) like they do on Earth ? They certainly change shape because of the resistance to movement provided by whatever they are moving in. for instance raindrops become pear shaped as they fall through the air resistance. However in space there is no resisting medium to cause this.
Phi for All Posted March 16 Posted March 16 On 3/16/2025 at 4:48 PM, Ralien said: I am at my post limit now as a new member so will not be able to further reply until tomorrow unfortunately . Expand I think you get 5 on your first day. It's an anti-spam measure.
iNow Posted March 16 Posted March 16 On 3/16/2025 at 6:06 PM, studiot said: Most new members don't. Expand As this was at least their 3rd sock puppet account and 4th total, they had a leg up on most noobs
Recommended Posts