Dave Posted March 3, 2006 Posted March 3, 2006 As this has been mentioned quite a lot, I thought we might as well give this a try. In order to keep this as civilized as possible, please read this carefully and make sure you re-read what you've written before you hit the post button! In this thread, you are allowed to nominate one member for each of the following six categories: Most Helpful Member: who gives the best answers in the nicest way? Most Knowledgeable Member: who displays the most consistent knowledge in any (or many) fields? Most Interesting Member: who's posts are a must read for their diverse content? Best Debater: the member who you think uses the best debating techniques on the forums. Most Enjoyable Member: this is a fun category; who makes you laugh the most? Most Improved Member: who has improved their quality of posts the most in the past twelve months? The Rules You are allowed to nominate one, and only one person for each category. Your last post on this thread will be counted as your vote; any previous posts will be deleted. Even so, please try and get it right the first time. Please do not nominate any members of staff or resident experts. If you do so, then these will be deleted. This is all about you guys in the community. Here is the Staff List. Please, reply to this post with the following format: Member name Member name Member name Member name Member name Member name Each member name corresponds to the appropriate category. Be careful not to mix them up, because we won't know and don't have the time to check! If you don't know how to format your post like this, then look at the BBCode Guide before you post. Any posts not of this form will be deleted. The mods will show no mercy on this point, since we have to go through all of these posts at the end of the day. [*]You are allowed to nominate one person for up to two different categories. [*]You are not allowed to nominate yourself. [*]If, for whatever reason, you do not wish to nominate somebody for a particular category, then please leave that name blank. However, you must submit a nomination for at least one category. [*]This thread will remain open for precisely one week. After that, no more nominations will be accepted. Please adhere to the rules. Any posts not complying with this will simply be deleted. This is supposed to be a bit of fun, but for this thread at least, we have to get it right. Remember, you've got one week to submit your nominations. Have fun!
bascule Posted March 3, 2006 Posted March 3, 2006 1. 5614 2. (Not in a position to judge this... so I'll pass) 3. AzurePhoenix 4. DV8 2XL 5. In My Memory 6. revprez/phcatlantis/patcalhoun/philcandless/pcs
Rakdos Posted March 4, 2006 Posted March 4, 2006 1.Bascule 2.YT2095 X Moderator 3.Sayonara X Administrator 4. 5.herme3 6.revprez/phcatlantis/patcalhoun/philcandless/pcs
ydoaPs Posted March 4, 2006 Posted March 4, 2006 1. 5614 2. In My Memory 3. In My Memory 4. 5. AzurePheonix 6. pcs/reprez
Phi for All Posted March 4, 2006 Posted March 4, 2006 To reiterate: Please do not nominate any members of staff or resident experts. If you do so, then these will be deleted. This is all about you guys in the community.
herpguy Posted March 4, 2006 Posted March 4, 2006 1. 5614 2. Ooo, toughy. Probably IMM. 3. Not sure, but I find ecoli's posts interesting. So ecoli. 4. Bascule 5. insane_alien 6. I haven't been here long enough to say.
Callipygous Posted March 4, 2006 Posted March 4, 2006 1. 5614 2. 3. 4. 5. azurephoenix 6. i dont pay enough attention to figure out which member i would nominate for the other positions, and im sort of confused about why the staff members arent eligible. you guys are an integral part of the community, and one of the catagories in staff is made up of people who have been specifically selected for their helpfulness and knowledge.
JustStuit Posted March 4, 2006 Posted March 4, 2006 1. Bascule Edit: Removed Martin since he's an expert 2. Edit: Removed Martin since he's an expert 3. Herpguy 4. Cap'n Refsmmat or Bascule Please choose one or the other. 5. AzurePhoenix 6. Pcs
In My Memory Posted March 4, 2006 Posted March 4, 2006 1. 5614 2. Jim 3. Bettina 4. Bascule 5. AzurePhoenix 6. yourdadonapogos
Phi for All Posted March 4, 2006 Posted March 4, 2006 im sort of confused about why the staff members arent eligible. you guys are an integral part of the communityThanks, but we can't be trusted with something this big. "Absolute power", that sort of thing.
AzurePhoenix Posted March 4, 2006 Posted March 4, 2006 1. Bettina maybe it's been a while, but I remember her being exceedingly sweet 2. IMM so many people in so many categories, but Memsy is always golden 3. Couldn't judge this if I tried 4. IMM never at a loss for words 5. I like too many peoples 6. can't say three outa six.... I feel so unfulfilled. Maybe if I could see their dueling techniques in a life or death battle match I could come up with more definate choices. Combatants, choose your weapons; we've got whisks, bug-zappers, hooked fishing rods and a Bible soaked in napalm.
Royston Posted March 4, 2006 Posted March 4, 2006 That was tough...there's so many good people in all those fields. 1. 5614 2. Ashennell 3. Bascule 4. In My Memory 5. insane_alien 6. pcs
Nevermore Posted March 4, 2006 Posted March 4, 2006 1. IMM 2. Bascule 3. AzurePhoexix 4. Pangloss X Moderator 5. AzurePhoenix 6. Pcs
silkworm Posted March 4, 2006 Posted March 4, 2006 1. ecoli 2. klaynos 3. bascule 4. bascule 5. Ryan J 6. sunspot
RyanJ Posted March 5, 2006 Posted March 5, 2006 1. 5614 2. insane_alien 3. Cap'n Refsmmat 4. AzurePhoenix 5. penagte. 6. [VOID - have not been here that long] There should be a seperate one for staff! Staff should have some sort of poll, its only fair Cheers, Ryan Jones
ecoli Posted March 5, 2006 Posted March 5, 2006 1.Capn Refsmmat 2. IMM 3. Azure Phoenix 4. YourdadonaPogos 5. AzurePhoenix 6. sunspot 1. Most Helpful Member: who gives the best answers in the nicest way? 2. Most Knowledgeable Member: who displays the most consistent knowledge in any (or many) fields? 3. Most Interesting Member: who's posts are a must read for their diverse content? 4. Best Debater: the member who you think uses the best debating techniques on the forums. 5. Most Enjoyable Member: this is a fun category; who makes you laugh the most? 6. Most Improved Member: who has improved their quality of posts the most in the past twelve months?
insane_alien Posted March 5, 2006 Posted March 5, 2006 1.IMM 2.Ecoli 3.Herpguy 4.Yourdadonapogos[tick] 5.AzurePhoenix 6.Not sure
5614 Posted March 5, 2006 Posted March 5, 2006 1. Dak 2. [a resident expert] 3. Bettina 4. [left blank] 5. AzurePhoenix 6. yourdadonapogos
-Demosthenes- Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 1. 2. 3. AzurePhoenix 4. IMM 5. AzurePhoenix 6.
mrblond5311 Posted March 6, 2006 Posted March 6, 2006 1. 5614 2. Even though we have our disagreements "ecoli is one smart guy" 3.AzurePhoenix 4.Bascule 5.AzurePhoenix amuses me 6.Can't say. Not as faithful as I'd like to be Lol, should we have one for the person who asks the most questions? Or perhaps the most intriguing?
Phi for All Posted March 9, 2006 Posted March 9, 2006 We really need more than 17 people posting nominations. If you haven't already participated in the SFN User Awards Nominations yet, please do it NOW!
YT2095 Posted March 10, 2006 Posted March 10, 2006 actualy I think it would be an idea to give this poll a 2 day extension, in all fairness, this place was down for a couple of days.
In My Memory Posted March 14, 2006 Posted March 14, 2006 Its been 13 days and the results are as follows: Most Helpful Most Knowledgable Most Interesting Best Debater Most Enjoyable Most Improved 5614 Ashennell AzurePhoenix DV8 2XL AzurePhoenix pcs 5614 Bascule AzurePhoenix AzurePhoenix AzurePhoenix pcs 5614 ecoli AzurePhoenix Bascule AzurePhoenix pcs 5614 Herpguy AzurePhoenix Bascule AzurePhoenix pcs 5614 In My Memory AzurePhoenix Bascule AzurePhoenix pcs 5614 In My Memory Bascule Bascule AzurePhoenix pcs 5614 In My Memory Bascule In My Memory AzurePhoenix sunspot 5614 In My Memory Bettina In My Memory AzurePhoenix sunspot Bascule insane_alien Bettina In My Memory AzurePhoenix yourdadonapogos Bascule Jim Cap'n Refsmmat yourdadonapogos AzurePhoenix yourdadonapogos Bettina Klaynos ecoli yourdadonapogos herme3 Cap'n Refsmmat Herpguy In My Memory Dak In My Memory insane_alien ecoli insane_alien In My Memory penagte In My Memory Ryan J 5614 (8) In My Memory (4) AzurePhoenix (5) Bascule (4) AzurePhoenix (10) pcs (6)
Phi for All Posted March 14, 2006 Posted March 14, 2006 Maybe Dave only needs to set up a voting poll for Best Debater. The rest seem to have pretty clear winners. He's going to decide later today.
Severian Posted March 14, 2006 Posted March 14, 2006 No, no no! These were nominations, not votes. So it doesn't make any difference how many times someone is nominated - it is only important that they are. So the vote for most helpful for example should now allow voting between 5614, Bascule, Cap'n Refsmmat, Dak, ecoli and IMM. At least that was how I understood 'nominations' to function!
Recommended Posts