Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Well, things may turn out different, than one just could say on the basis of the activities series. The latter is not really applicable in situations where solid mixtures are heated.

 

I can imagine that the Zn can reduce the carbonate ion when sufficient heat is applied and if that indeed happens, I expect the following:

 

Zn + CaCO3 --> ZnO + CaO + CO

Posted

I'll go with zinc reducing aswell - its used in the lab all the time in inorganic reactions as a reductant (itself oxidised! OilRig!).

 

Matt

Posted
Well, things may turn out different, than one just could say on the basis of the activities series. The latter is not really applicable in situations where solid mixtures are heated.

 

I can imagine that the Zn can reduce the carbonate ion when sufficient heat is applied and if that indeed happens, I expect the following:

 

Zn + CaCO3 --> ZnO + CaO + CO

 

I assume Zn will accept an O because of how its valence electrons are ordered, but the above reaction leads me to two questions: 1) how can you predict the electron dot structure of a transition metal? and 2) would every Zn ion react with every one out of three oxygen ions, and if not, wouldnt that lead to a reversible reaction?

Posted

Ad 1) This depends on the electronic structure of the element itself. For transition metals, however, things are more diffuse, because they can exist in multiple oxidation states (zinc is an exception, however) and because they can form complexes with many things.

 

Ad 2) Not all oxygens will be bonded to zinc. Calcium will not be set free in this reaction, it will also remain in the +2 oxidation state, requiring an oxygen atom. Carbon also certainly will not be set free, but at the high temperatures involved, CO2 is not likely to occur. If that would occur, then we would have simple decomposition of chalk, without oxidation of zinc. Hence the expectation of CO, CaO and ZnO.

Posted

I`m also in agreement with Woelen here, CO2 will be produced initially but as the temp rises it also will split, leaving CO to escape, the carbonates of both calcium and zinc are easily destroyed with heat, you`ll never rip that oxygen off though, not without some Serious reducing power in there and/or extreme heat.

  • 6 years later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.