Big-Daddy Posted June 18, 2012 Posted June 18, 2012 Hi, sorry if this is a stupid mistake or I should be ignoring Wikipedia, I'd just like clarity. As I understand it, the concentration of H3O+ ions in an acidic solution is denoted by (x^3)+(Ka*(x^2))-((Kw*x)+(C*Ka*x))-(Kw*Ka)=0 (where x is the concentration of H3O+ ions, C is the starting concentration of acid molecules, Ka is the acid dissociation constant and Kw is the auto-ionization constant of water. My question is, assuming that the above is correct (if it's not please correct me), is it safe to describe the concentration of OH- ions in an alkaline solution with (x^3)+(Kb*(x^2))-((Kw*x)+(C*Kb*x))-(Kw*Kb)=0 (where x is now the concentration of OH- ions instead)? The doubt arises because Wikipedia says that "For alkaline solutions an additional term is added to the mass-balance equation for hydrogen. Since addition of hydroxide reduces the hydrogen ion concentration, and the hydroxide ion concentration is constrained by the self-ionization equilibrium to be equal to Kw/[H+]", so it appears that, in the alkaline equation, I should simply keep x=concentration of H3O+ and replace all the current 'x's with 'Kw/x' (which will thus be equal to the concentration of OH-). But I don't see why that's necessary - can't I just use (x^3)+(Kb*(x^2))-((Kw*x)+(C*Kb*x))-(Kw*Kb)=0 where x is the concentration of OH- ions for my calculation? If I want to calculate H3O+ ions additionally, can't I just use [H3O+]*[OH-]=Kw after I solve the cubic above? E.G. If I want to calculate the H3O+ ionic concentration in an alkaline solution, can't I just use (x^3)+(Kb*(x^2))-((Kw*x)+(C*Kb*x))-(Kw*Kb)=0 where x is the concentration of OH- ions and then use [H3O+]=Kw/[OH-]? If so, why does Wikipedia suggest using a Kw/[H3O+] system? If not, where am I going wrong? Thanks a lot for any help.
Bioc Posted June 19, 2012 Posted June 19, 2012 I think wikipedia puts it that way because you are calculating the pH. If you use Kb and [OH-] then you are calculating the pOH. Anyway, pH +pOH = 14, so it must be a convention thing.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now