need help Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 (edited) I am seriously lost with Proofs. I am allowed to use Rules of Inference (MP, MT, HS, Simp, AD, Conj, CD, and DS) and Rules of Equivalence (AB, Dem, Com, Assn, Dist, DN, Cont, MI, EX, ME, and RE) Here are the ones I am working on right now. Any help would be greatly appreciated. #15 1. (A∨B)∙(A∨G) 2. M→~A 3. ~Q→(~B∨~G) ∴ M→Q #16 1. Y∙(~N∨A) 2. ~Y∨N 3. (A∙Y)→~~K ∴ K #17 1. ~G→~F 2. (~F∨G)→(H∨J) 3. H→Z 4. J→~P ∴ P→Z #18 1. (D∙E)∨(~D∙~E) 2. (H∙J)→~(D↔E) 3. ~~H∨J ∴ J↔~H #19 1. (~E∨Z)∙(~E∨W) 2. ~K→E 3. ~K→(~Z∨~W) 4. K↔U ∴ R→U #20 1. (R∙S)∨(R∙~E) 2. (Y∙O)→(E∙~S) 3. (O→~Y)→L ∴ L #21 1. ~E 2. ~(E∙D)→F 3. (~F ∨ B)∙(~F∨C) ∴A∨(B∙C) #22 1. T →R 2. R→S 3. ~R↔S ∴~T∙S #23 1. (~K→K)→~L 2. ~(~L→~M)→L 3. M ∴ K↔~L #24 1. W 2. ~Y→(~W∙~X) ∴ Y∙[(~W∙~X)→Z] #25 1. F∨~I 2. I∨H 3. ~(G↔J)→~H ∴ [(~G∨~J)∙(G∨J)]→F Edited June 24, 2012 by need help
ydoaPs Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 Two things: 1) Are you allowed to use Condition Proof and Indirect Proof methods? 2) What have you tried so far? (we're not in the business of doing homework, but we'll help you get the answer yourself) 1
need help Posted June 24, 2012 Author Posted June 24, 2012 Two things: 1) Are you allowed to use Condition Proof and Indirect Proof methods? 2) What have you tried so far? (we're not in the business of doing homework, but we'll help you get the answer yourself) 1) We have not gotten to Condition Proofs yet that is next. Not sure what indirect proof method is. 2) That is exactly what I want. I want to learn it not have someone do it for me. I need guidance on what to do. If I have the rules I can figure it out or when I have the answers and have to figure out which rule applies but when I have to try to map it all and figure out what rules lead to what answers to get to the end I get lost. I just need some direction and hints on what I need to do.
ydoaPs Posted June 24, 2012 Posted June 24, 2012 1) We have not gotten to Condition Proofs yet that is next. Not sure what indirect proof method is. 2) That is exactly what I want. I want to learn it not have someone do it for me. I need guidance on what to do. If I have the rules I can figure it out or when I have the answers and have to figure out which rule applies but when I have to try to map it all and figure out what rules lead to what answers to get to the end I get lost. I just need some direction and hints on what I need to do. We'll start with an easy one. Try number 16 and think double negation. 1
need help Posted June 24, 2012 Author Posted June 24, 2012 (edited) We'll start with an easy one. Try number 16 and think double negation. 4. (A∙Y)→K 3, DN [cond] 5. (Y∙~N)∨(Y∙A) 1, Dist [disj] 6. ~~(Y∙~N)∨(Y∙A) 5, DN [disj] 7. ~(~Y∨~~N)∨(Y∙A) 6, DeM [disj] 8. ~Y∨~~N 2, DN [disj] 9. ~~(~Y∨~~N) 8, DN [nega] 10. (Y∙A) 9,7, DS [conj] 11. (A∙Y) 10, Com [conj] 12. K 4,11, MP [atom] Congratulations: No errors were found in the proof. Edited June 24, 2012 by need help
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now