Does Bob Holdom's particle suggest existence of "sublte body"?

[Alexander1304]

Hello all,

Recently,I've been at one forum discussinig the mind/body problem and "hard problem of conciousness".Well,there one one person who claimed that existence of "mirror matter" is the most likely resolution for mind/body problem. But he used the quotation about "mirror photons" proposed by Bob Holdom,here:

"According to Bob Holdom, of the University of Toronto, says that photons and mirror photons, (along with other particles and their mirror counterparts) can change into each other through the exchange of a "Holdom force" particle, or H particle. Mirror photons, in theory, can interact with regular photons. However, the mirror photon can not interact with any charged particle, it can only interact with its neutral counterpart, the regular photon."Following that, he concluded that Holdom's solutioin presupposes the existence of "subtle body".But is it logical conclusion?

Any thoughts?

[Moontanman]

Hello all,

Recently,I've been at one forum discussinig the mind/body problem and "hard problem of conciousness".Well,there one one person who claimed that existence of "mirror matter" is the most likely resolution for mind/body problem. But he used the quotation about "mirror photons" proposed by Bob Holdom,here:

"According to Bob Holdom, of the University of Toronto, says that photons and mirror photons, (along with other particles and their mirror counterparts) can change into each other through the exchange of a "Holdom force" particle, or H particle. Mirror photons, in theory, can interact with regular photons. However, the mirror photon can not interact with any charged particle, it can only interact with its neutral counterpart, the regular photon."Following that, he concluded that Holdom's solutioin presupposes the existence of "subtle body".But is it logical conclusion?

Any thoughts?

 

 

I've exchanged messages with Dr. Foot about mirror matter, he has yet to show it's existence, this seems like quite a divergence from what he describes in his Book.

 

http://books.google.com/books/about/Shadowlands.html?id=3evE2K-ylVIC

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirror_matter

 

http://www.technologyreview.com/view/418687/first-evidence-that-mirror-matter-may-fill-the/

[Alexander1304]

The point here ,that there is some "mediator" between mirror and ordinary particles,that change mirror particles into the ordinary and vice-versa...and thus,if it exists innour bodies,then another(mirror matter) body is created

Edited August 20, 2012 by Alexander1304