Jump to content

John Cuthber

Resident Experts
  • Posts

    18374
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    49

John Cuthber last won the day on October 29

John Cuthber had the most liked content!

About John Cuthber

  • Birthday 11/10/1965

Profile Information

  • Location
    England

Retained

  • Chemistry Expert

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

John Cuthber's Achievements

SuperNerd

SuperNerd (12/13)

4.1k

Reputation

  1. In the particular case of the CuAuAg system, I think the colour would give you a hint. If you measured the reflectance spectrum carefully, it would probably be sufficient. The electrical conductivity might also work, or the hardness, or the speed of sound, or the melting point or magnetic susceptibility or the electrode potential or melting point. But the point remains; you need something to tell you where on that line you are. If you are in the UK and there's a point on the line corresponding to 9 (or 18) carat gold then that's a fair bet, but no proof. But in the USA they seem to prefer 10 carat (as far as I can tell).
  2. So... if I tell you the density of the alloy is 10.5, you can tell me it has a composition which lies on that Isopycnic line. But you can't tell me which composition it is. In other words, you can't tell me anything that Archimedes couldn't have
  3. No, and nor can you. Feel free to post your double blind trial data if you don't agree with me.
  4. Cast iron will crack due to uneven thermal expansion if you are not careful.
  5. No, it's not. If you think I'm wrong, it's up to you to prove it.
  6. The clever bit about those is not the choice of material so much as the big gaps. That means they are less troubled by expansion. They don't buckle and warp because, for the most part, they can just expand a bit. They use cast iron because it's strong enough, has a high enough melting point, and it's cheap. A sheet of cast iron would only be slightly better than a sheet of glass.
  7. Looks like a theoretical solution in search of a problem.
  8. Repeatedly taking away a debt is the same as repeatedly adding a credit.
  9. Copper is less dense than silver. Gold is more dense than silver. Therefore there is a binary alloy of copper and gold which has exactly the same density as silver. We can call it "match" because it has a density that matches that of silver. An alloy of mainly copper with a little gold will be slightly more dense than copper. We can refer to this alloy as "light" and similarly we can have an alloy, which we can call "heavy" made from mainly gold with a little copper. If we start with pure silver we can add a small amount of heavy which will raise the density, and then we can add light to reduce the density. The overall effect will be to produce an alloy which has the same density as silver and which is a ternary alloy. We can repeat that process and get a second alloy- again containing all 3 metals and which has exactly the same density as silver. It will have a different composition from the first one. And we can , add further amounts of light and compensating amounts of heavy until we get arbitrarily close to "match". All these alloys have the same density as silver. How does your method distinguish among them? (The option of extending this to have an alloy with, for example, a density half way between that of gold and silver or whatever also exists)
  10. I think we should tell everyone that. And then the Reps will get complacent and teh Dems will get determined. Anyone remember how the UK's Brexit referendum played out? We all knew that it would fail...
  11. I see the OP thinks misquoting me is helpful. Mind you; he's not entirely wrong. When I asked how he planned to do meaningless magic, I was implicitly pointing out that he was talking kak. But while I will give him the benefit of the doubt and assume his use of "Kak" means "why" (Maybe Russian , Ukrainian Polish or whatever) , my use of it is more like the Dutch.
  12. I don't know who will win. I don't thinks anyone does. But here's a hint about who I would like to win.
  13. There's this https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/wilhelmina-ice-pole-sitting-contest and also everyday life in Scotland.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.